2024 Red Bull Hardline

ryan_daugherty
Posts
117
Joined
8/1/2009
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
2234th
5/27/2024 7:59am

Yeah, Hardline is great but seeing it go this direction makes it feel like a sideshow to try and pull in clips views on social media. Shitloads of people are going to share clips of this jump but those folks likely won't know what the event is, or even what the sport is. I know this concept was created by Dan to make a race with the biggest more technical features on it and I totally understand that but it seems to me that this is entering try hard vs something genuinely good for the sport or even interestingly. Don't get me wrong, I don't care if riders decide that they want to ride this stuff, that's fully up to them, hell they can hold the race and add fire rings to jump through for all I care if that's what the riders want but I'd love to see Redbull enlist Dan's talents and allocate the resources they're putting into this into creating a fully fledged, real World Cup alternative that's free of the UCI, has new/interesting tracks in new and interesting locations with big prize purses. 

As for this feature, I don't think anyone would think less of RB or the builders if they came out and said after experimenting here they're pulling this feature and going back to the OG track. Personally I like tracks that are steep with more technical moves vs super high speed with big jumps, this goes for hardline too. The big jumps aren't interesting, the steep rock moves are. 

14
5/27/2024 8:18am Edited Date/Time 5/27/2024 8:19am

A couple of points I haven't seen brought up.

1. There is zero margin for error on the run in of that jump. What happens when it's muddy and someone slides out at the bottom of the run in and goes off the side of the ramp? That's looks to be substantially higher than the gap is wide? 

2. This is for sure a feature that gets shut down by a stiff breeze. There doesn't look to be an alternative route. Is this feature the reason Hardline gets cancelled this year?  Big jumps make it more likely that weather causes a cancellation than more technical routes that could be run in the wet/ wind. 

6
O1D4
Posts
61
Joined
10/20/2018
Location
Vancouver CA
Fantasy
1002nd
5/27/2024 11:11am
veefour wrote:

that photo is mesmerizing on so many levels...

9
gibbon
Posts
439
Joined
3/7/2019
Location
GB
5/27/2024 11:36am
LePigPen wrote:
Part of the story that is missing is... Come event time a LOT of people were over shooting tbh. I'm not sure how many were in...

Part of the story that is missing is... Come event time a LOT of people were over shooting tbh. I'm not sure how many were in any danger of under shooting. I'm still under the impression that Dave had a weird go and maybe wasn't the man to test it. I'm not sure how different the soil was at the time. I'm also still under the impression it was generally a good decision to pull it back, but consider its a race and people are happily going no brake down the end. You may have needed to take 1% kick off the lip to do so. Luckily riders adjusted fine mostly. But damn some of those over shots were scary.

Random thoughts-
-I find it hard to believe Dan was directly involved in the construction of the canyon gap and that appalling hip monstrosity ( I recognized a few of the builders on the vids)
-He is probably the most experienced builder of big trail features (if you've ridden Dyfi you'll know how good he is) in the uk and having been super seriously injured himself and seeing what his brother went through I could'nt see him signing off on something he was'nt 100% with (he hurt himself guinea pigging the lily pad/90ft's before anyone else).
-I don't know Dan super well (since the Commencal days) but I know him well enough to know that he takes this shit super seriously.
-Gee is always super busy doing his own stuff somewhere.
-Also it being so unfinished only a week before the event seems  so wrong.
-Matt Jones (ignoring personal dramas) seems like a nice guy and can jump a bike (not so good on technical stuff) but he seemed waaay out of his depth (here and in Tassie) and maybe not the brightest cookie.
-BK has taken on the mantle as 'the tester' .....realistically if he said 'nope' I could'nt see anyone else riding it and with only a week to go, there's goes hardline. That's a lot of pressure to get'er done.

8
LePigPen
Posts
374
Joined
12/23/2020
Location
Harbor City, CA US
Fantasy
151st
5/27/2024 11:57am

I am just baffled, as Spomer and Jason said I believe, that you basically have a distance that seems about the exact distance of the standardized mega ramp for X Games. You have the backing of Red Bull. And therefore the backing of basically anyone including Travis Pastrana and his Nitro Circus crew and builders.

You have as far as I can see every resource you could possibly want for this specific scenario... And you eye ball it? You just draw it on a napkin and call it a day?

I'm guessing the big obstacle was, as you build the roll in. You start to run out of space for how the transitions even out. They wanted a flat spot so people could speed check braking and 'set up' for the jump, and it turned it into an even worse proposition. I'm not sure how much more room they can gain given it looks nearly set in stone (literally?) at this point. But if they even try to fix it the ramp will then become a fully rounded transition roll in to ramp, that may be harder to brake check on. And you can add any net you want down there... Nobody wants to free fall off the edge and trust the netting from the builders who couldn't get the ramp good first try. :/

5
Stewyeww
Posts
200
Joined
6/10/2021
Location
CA
5/27/2024 12:07pm

You're right.  This totally is 'Mountain Biking'.  I bet the 'Ski Biking' event this past winter caused you to faint and have the vapors...  

How is that in any way related to this? 

dolface
Posts
1216
Joined
10/26/2015
Location
CA US
Fantasy
610th
5/27/2024 12:07pm
gibbon wrote:
Random thoughts- -I find it hard to believe Dan was directly involved in the construction of the canyon gap and that appalling hip monstrosity ( I...

Random thoughts-
-I find it hard to believe Dan was directly involved in the construction of the canyon gap and that appalling hip monstrosity ( I recognized a few of the builders on the vids)
-He is probably the most experienced builder of big trail features (if you've ridden Dyfi you'll know how good he is) in the uk and having been super seriously injured himself and seeing what his brother went through I could'nt see him signing off on something he was'nt 100% with (he hurt himself guinea pigging the lily pad/90ft's before anyone else).
-I don't know Dan super well (since the Commencal days) but I know him well enough to know that he takes this shit super seriously.
-Gee is always super busy doing his own stuff somewhere.
-Also it being so unfinished only a week before the event seems  so wrong.
-Matt Jones (ignoring personal dramas) seems like a nice guy and can jump a bike (not so good on technical stuff) but he seemed waaay out of his depth (here and in Tassie) and maybe not the brightest cookie.
-BK has taken on the mantle as 'the tester' .....realistically if he said 'nope' I could'nt see anyone else riding it and with only a week to go, there's goes hardline. That's a lot of pressure to get'er done.

*couldn't, wasn't Laughing

1
1
5/27/2024 1:34pm

BK needs a place in MTB hall of fame. The guy is so dedicated to making MTB racing better and the overal appeal for riders and viewers.
 

2
10
bulletbass man
Posts
914
Joined
8/18/2018
Location
Collegeville, PA US
Fantasy
169th
5/27/2024 2:45pm

Personally I don’t like the look of it.  Got a beautiful welsh mountainside with this wierd and ugly giant rollin, jump, and landing built onto it.  But I’m sure it will look pretty epic on camera and that’s what they are going for. And while hardline often gets called off for wind.  With a wooden run in they should be able to hit it if it’s wet as will it roll just as fast.

I have zero experience with features of this size but the lip looks like less of a problem than the transition from the rollin and the very short run up to the lip.

I do find it hilarious they bothered with foam pads at the bottom they usually use on the back of a case pad.  As if they are going to make any difference when you are falling 90 or more feet going 30-40 mph forward.

8
danielteleman
Posts
30
Joined
1/16/2023
Location
Ponferrada, León ES
Fantasy
1593rd
5/27/2024 3:12pm
Which builder? The crash I know of was McMillan casing the creek gap, and I've seen the footage and talked to people there and he rode...

Which builder? The crash I know of was McMillan casing the creek gap, and I've seen the footage and talked to people there and he rode of with so little speed he almost landed in the creek. People legit thought he was testing the run up he was going that slow. That crash was on him. 

My point is we have technology to make jumps safer these days. It can be calculated, you look at angles of takeoff, total distance, and speed gained from run in, and heck even a speed gun. 

The curves they built of the gap are just bad, there so sharp. The wooden hip is the same, it's a tight curve then heaps of flat after, that's not a nice takeoff

swoopswoop wrote:
If it was just on Dave, how come they changed the jump afterwards? When Dave revealed his injuries, other riders commented suggesting there was something up...

If it was just on Dave, how come they changed the jump afterwards? When Dave revealed his injuries, other riders commented suggesting there was something up with the jump itself too. It seems he was a bit slow for it but that wasn't the only factor. 

They knew they wouldn't have enough speed in the wet for it to be safe, so they shortened it so it could be ridden in all...

They knew they wouldn't have enough speed in the wet for it to be safe, so they shortened it so it could be ridden in all conditions. 

The outcome is you saw in the dry they were gapping to the flat pretty much on race runs. 

Dave's crash was bizarre. Nobody quite knows why he took so little speed into it. 

They actually cut the course short, where it finished was actually meant to be a huge sharkfin step down that got canned. You can see the banking in the finish area that was meant to be the sharkfin in the broadcast. 

What i cant understand is why they dont protect the casing/face of the ramp with a big inflatable. That would reduce danger in big jumps testing

1
markb2392
Posts
18
Joined
12/16/2022
Location
Guildford GB
5/28/2024 5:38am
BK needs a place in MTB hall of fame. The guy is so dedicated to making MTB racing better and the overal appeal for riders and...

BK needs a place in MTB hall of fame. The guy is so dedicated to making MTB racing better and the overal appeal for riders and viewers.
 

BK needs a place on a register.....

9
6
amaranth
Posts
48
Joined
10/19/2023
Location
Nutley, NJ US
Fantasy
137th
5/28/2024 7:44am

Less than a week away from the event, which happens to be a DH RACE, and they haven't dialed in all the features yet. Even rampage gets 4 days of practice - and you get to choose your own lines/features. Can't help but think they had something go wrong schedule wise...

2
Big Bird
Posts
2171
Joined
2/1/2011
Location
Oceano, CA US
5/28/2024 9:47am

The hip and the canyon gap take the riders across the river and back again. I'm guessing they will just scratch out a connector trail to keep things on the one side of the waterfall. 

4
saskskier
Posts
77
Joined
11/4/2017
Location
CA
Fantasy
958th
5/28/2024 1:55pm

Part of me is skeptical, not having heard anything from any other sources. Part of me is disappointed if it's true (especially if they were re-working the take off). Part of me is relieved because I don't want to see anyone hurt and weather/wind always plays such a big factor in whether or not the event actually takes place. 

If the riders said it's not going to work, I support it. If someone else said they shouldn't do it even if the riders still wanted it, I'm less happy. 

2
dolface
Posts
1216
Joined
10/26/2015
Location
CA US
Fantasy
610th
5/28/2024 3:33pm
saskskier wrote:
Part of me is skeptical, not having heard anything from any other sources. Part of me is disappointed if it's true (especially if they were re-working...

Part of me is skeptical, not having heard anything from any other sources. Part of me is disappointed if it's true (especially if they were re-working the take off). Part of me is relieved because I don't want to see anyone hurt and weather/wind always plays such a big factor in whether or not the event actually takes place. 

If the riders said it's not going to work, I support it. If someone else said they shouldn't do it even if the riders still wanted it, I'm less happy. 

From the PB primer: "It sounds like there will be a safety net added and the lip will be changed ahead of the race."

Singletracks says it's out entirely: "We’ve been informed by a source at the event that the organisers have decided not to include the canyon gap jump as part of the Red Bull Hardline course."

1
saskskier
Posts
77
Joined
11/4/2017
Location
CA
Fantasy
958th
5/28/2024 3:40pm
saskskier wrote:
Part of me is skeptical, not having heard anything from any other sources. Part of me is disappointed if it's true (especially if they were re-working...

Part of me is skeptical, not having heard anything from any other sources. Part of me is disappointed if it's true (especially if they were re-working the take off). Part of me is relieved because I don't want to see anyone hurt and weather/wind always plays such a big factor in whether or not the event actually takes place. 

If the riders said it's not going to work, I support it. If someone else said they shouldn't do it even if the riders still wanted it, I'm less happy. 

dolface wrote:
From the PB primer: "It sounds like there will be a safety net added and the lip will be changed ahead of the race." Singletracks says...

From the PB primer: "It sounds like there will be a safety net added and the lip will be changed ahead of the race."

Singletracks says it's out entirely: "We’ve been informed by a source at the event that the organisers have decided not to include the canyon gap jump as part of the Red Bull Hardline course."

Seems like it'll just be lots of speculation until there's an official announcement. 

2
LePigPen
Posts
374
Joined
12/23/2020
Location
Harbor City, CA US
Fantasy
151st
5/28/2024 4:50pm

That won't convince the type of reader who thinks this is some kind of injustice and jeopardizing the core rep of the event or whatever their angle is I have no idea. They won't be happy until Gee himself knocks on their door, shakes their hand, and tells them they're using the old course. I like how it's bothering some people we won't see people risk the canyon jump. Keeps em up at night. They wanted hardline not softline. They want blood guts n gore

2
saskskier
Posts
77
Joined
11/4/2017
Location
CA
Fantasy
958th
5/28/2024 5:28pm
LePigPen wrote:
That won't convince the type of reader who thinks this is some kind of injustice and jeopardizing the core rep of the event or whatever their...

That won't convince the type of reader who thinks this is some kind of injustice and jeopardizing the core rep of the event or whatever their angle is I have no idea. They won't be happy until Gee himself knocks on their door, shakes their hand, and tells them they're using the old course. I like how it's bothering some people we won't see people risk the canyon jump. Keeps em up at night. They wanted hardline not softline. They want blood guts n gore

I have no interest in blood, guts and gore. I have an interest in riders having the autonomy to make their own decisions about what they want to ride and/or how far they want to progress.

It shouldn't be up to the viewers that thinks that new blue flow trail was a rowdy good time to decide what the very best riders should or shouldn't ride. 

2
LePigPen
Posts
374
Joined
12/23/2020
Location
Harbor City, CA US
Fantasy
151st
5/28/2024 5:33pm

Wait do you think the viewers closed the canyon gap?

Do you... Do you think viewers have EVER had ANY effect on Hardline/Rampage or even WC courses tbh?

1
saskskier
Posts
77
Joined
11/4/2017
Location
CA
Fantasy
958th
5/28/2024 5:41pm
LePigPen wrote:
Wait do you think the viewers closed the canyon gap? Do you... Do you think viewers have EVER had ANY effect on Hardline/Rampage or even WC...

Wait do you think the viewers closed the canyon gap?

Do you... Do you think viewers have EVER had ANY effect on Hardline/Rampage or even WC courses tbh?

I honestly have no idea, but in all my years of riding and following races/events/etc, I've never seen this kind of pushback from fans to shut down a feature. I've never seen petitions for Gee (or other riders) to calm down. 

Like I said, if the riders are calling it, great. If they (or the organizers) are bowing to the pressure, even if they've made is safer and/or easier to ride, not awesome. 

Regardless, there still hasn't been any kind of announcement, so it's still just speculation. 

2
1
LePigPen
Posts
374
Joined
12/23/2020
Location
Harbor City, CA US
Fantasy
151st
5/28/2024 5:54pm

Oh I was literally joking. There's ZERO chance viewers have any say on this. You think Gee would give a flying fuck?

From what I heard the reason it's not happening is a) they couldn't get a decent netting solution up in time and b) sounds like they ran against a timeframe to actually fix the jumps. I'd even be convinced they didn't think the fix was feasible. From what I can see the reason the transition is so tight is just literally physical space. Could mellow the lip, but you still have a G out issue on the run in. So the only solution would be rounding the entire thing out which makes speed checking VERY hard. Which means you absolutely need a net if people are struggling to brake cuz there isnt a flat spot to do so.

Or literally a million other reasons lol. It's just a bad design. Hopefully they get it next year. But all 3 riders who rode it said it was dogshit and the hip was so bad they didn't even attempt it lol. Nothing to do with viewers. Just bad design and short on time.

8
saskskier
Posts
77
Joined
11/4/2017
Location
CA
Fantasy
958th
5/28/2024 6:12pm
LePigPen wrote:
Oh I was literally joking. There's ZERO chance viewers have any say on this. You think Gee would give a flying fuck? From what I heard...

Oh I was literally joking. There's ZERO chance viewers have any say on this. You think Gee would give a flying fuck?

From what I heard the reason it's not happening is a) they couldn't get a decent netting solution up in time and b) sounds like they ran against a timeframe to actually fix the jumps. I'd even be convinced they didn't think the fix was feasible. From what I can see the reason the transition is so tight is just literally physical space. Could mellow the lip, but you still have a G out issue on the run in. So the only solution would be rounding the entire thing out which makes speed checking VERY hard. Which means you absolutely need a net if people are struggling to brake cuz there isnt a flat spot to do so.

Or literally a million other reasons lol. It's just a bad design. Hopefully they get it next year. But all 3 riders who rode it said it was dogshit and the hip was so bad they didn't even attempt it lol. Nothing to do with viewers. Just bad design and short on time.

Ha ha. All fair points. I don't think Gee cares, but the higher ups might. 

If they pull it from the race (and can make it work a bit better), it'd be cool to have a session with athletes that want to hit it. After some reflection though, I also think that the weather is such a crapshoot at the best of times, I actually think it'd be ridiculously good luck to get a window where the wind wouldn't shut that thing down.

Curious what they do instead if it's off the table. 

2
LePigPen
Posts
374
Joined
12/23/2020
Location
Harbor City, CA US
Fantasy
151st
5/28/2024 6:29pm

That was my take. It makes almost zero sense in a race format. Particularly one that was literally cancelled the year before due to wind (and presumably the 90s, which if they had proper go arounds maybe they could justify running in the wind?).

Rebuilt correctly, on for a filming session. It's a GREAT free ride feature. Already produced photo of the year with Jim's bail flight from down low. But as a race feature it makes about zero sense. This should have all been figured out as a freeride feature a while ago, and once perfected, THEN considered for the race. (Not the other way around.)

4
Stewyeww
Posts
200
Joined
6/10/2021
Location
CA
5/28/2024 7:35pm

Probably time to jump down from that high horse your on and take a breather

1
2

Post a reply to: 2024 Red Bull Hardline

The Latest